Bhang Bhang Duc

Did you see the dummy-spit Cormac performed in the NSSC forums? Got him a forum ban from the Mods and probably a pile of voters changing their votes. Classic.

It’s a nicely judged proposal from LD - well worth supporting I think.

Definitely cats - well that’s what my cat told me to say.

GA law is not my area of expertise (SC yes) so I cannot really comment apart from possibly the “Remarking” clause - reads a bit like a NatSov reason which tends to weaken the overall argument.

Okay it’s not a bad first attempt, mostly legal. Game created region is, as has been noted previously, an R4 violation. I suspect the mention of players in Protecting Our Players Accord is also an R4 violation, though it might be best to get a Mod ruling on that. The biggest issue for me is that all you’ve really given is a list of roles/positions held by Halo. There is no detail on how he influenced the region or the NS community at large, the achievements in the various roles. Good Commendations (and Condemnations) are built on detailed research, not laundry lists. Have a look at the recent Commends/Condemns that have passed the SC. Read up on some of the ones that failed as well and see how much work has gone into the writing of both types. My notes above are pretty close to the reaction you would get if you published the current draft in the NS SC forum.

A belated “hi” from me - welcome to TWP. Think I’ve seen you on the GP and SC forums?

For. Yes it’s RP, but it’s a well written and researched Commendation, and that, to me should be the deciding factor.

It’s Drunken Conquerors - what do you expect? Backed up by that other perennial dirtbag Block.

Thanks Winni. Got locked out again late yesterday (my GMT) time - just left it to reset this time.

I’ve been locked out of my account twice now by the same little shit (Casmar was his forum handle) that’s been stalking Dave. Dark reset my password for me after I managed to stuff that up.

Insidious yes. Cuddly? Not so much. Oh yes, welcome.

I’m against the repeal, based solely on who the author is. Bitely’s like Jocospor, thinks money and stamps can buy him GA/SC proposal passes.

It’s all moot. The repeal bill was challenged and has been found to be illegal by the Secretariat. If it passes (unlikely at the time of writing) it will be discarded.

It’s well written and researched, which I would expect from Kuriko. I’m going to say that from a personal point of view it does enough for me to vote in favour of it.

Welcome to the forums Novas.